Ankuzef Temel Hukuk Ünite 2 Deneme Sınavı
https://lolonolo.com/2026/10/01/ankuzef-temel-hukuk-unite-2-deneme-sinavi/
Ankuzef Temel Hukuk Ünite 2 Deneme Sınavı | Maddî Kaynak ve Şeklî Kaynak Ayrımı | Türk Hukukunun Kaynaklarına İlişkin Üç Temel Özellik | Anayasa | Kanun | Uluslararası Antlaşmalar | Cumhurbaşkanlığı Kararnamesi | OHAL Cumhurbaşkanlığı Kararnameleri, KHK ve Tüzük | Yönetmelik ve Adsız Düzenleyici İşlemler | Yazısız Asıl Kaynak: Örf ve Adet Hukuku | Yardımcı Kaynaklar: Mahkeme Kararları ve Öğreti | Sınava Hazırlık Önerileri
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
Alright, if you're ready, let's dive
0:01
right into the subject. Welcome to our
0:03
brand-new analysis where we'll decode
0:05
the Turkish legal system. Today, we are
0:07
putting on the table those massive and
0:09
complex sets of rules that hold our
0:11
society together, in other words, the
0:13
core sources that shape the law.
0:15
Moreover, while doing this, I want you
0:17
to visualize a very clear image in your
0:19
mind. A giant power pyramid. Our rule
0:21
is incredibly simple, folks. The rules
0:24
at the top always, and I mean always,
0:25
override the ones below. That is
0:27
exactly how the hierarchy of norms
0:29
works. Keep your eyes peeled. Because
0:31
once you grasp this rigid structure,
0:33
those laws, decrees, and regulations we
0:35
constantly hear about in the news will
0:37
fall right into place in your mind. Now
0:39
, let's make a small distinction before
0:41
we get into the details. Today, we are
0:43
setting aside the reasons why law
0:44
emerges entirely. Meaning, we won't be
0:46
dealing with the sociology or the
0:48
history of it. We won't be
0:49
philosophizing. Our focus is purely
0:51
practical; we will concentrate on where
0:54
and how the law appears before us, that
0:56
is, the formal sources. In the current
0:58
system, in which document and under
1:00
what name do these rules materialize?
1:01
That is exactly what we are looking at
1:03
here. Here is our roadmap as we descend
1:05
downward. First, the summit, which is
1:07
the constitution. Then, on the second
1:09
step, laws and treaties. On the third
1:12
step, there are presidential decrees.
1:14
Just below that, at the base, are the
1:16
regulations. Then, our unwritten source
1:19
: customary law, and finally, auxiliary
1:21
sources. Let's climb the pyramid.
1:24
Section 1: The summit. The Constitution
1:27
. This is indisputably the highest
1:29
point. The constitution is not just
1:31
some simple rulebook. It is the state's
1:34
identity card, and changing it is
1:35
intentionally made very difficult. Of
1:37
course, this summit has changed a lot
1:39
from yesterday to today. We started
1:41
with the 1876 first Ottoman
1:42
Constitution, the Kanuni Esasi. In the
1:45
early republican period, the 1921 and
1:47
1924 constitutions came into play. Then
1:50
came the 1961, and ultimately, the 1982
1:52
constitution with that famous rigid
1:55
structure we still use today. So, what
1:57
does it really mean for a constitution
1:59
to be rigid? This is where the numbers
2:02
speak. For example, 200. To even just
2:04
propose a constitutional amendment to
2:06
the Grand National Assembly of Turkey,
2:08
the wet signatures of at least 200
2:10
deputies are required. Look, I'm not
2:12
even talking about changing it. You
2:14
need this massive number just to open
2:16
this topic in parliament. Things are
2:18
truly serious. So, what about passing
2:20
it through parliament? That's where the
2:22
number 360 comes into play. Let's say
2:24
you submitted the proposal. Secret
2:26
ballots were held. For this amendment
2:28
to pass the parliament, at least
2:29
three-fifths of the total number of
2:31
assembly members, exactly 360 deputies,
2:33
must say yes. If the votes are stuck
2:36
between 360 and 399, and the President
2:38
does not send it back to the parliament
2:40
, the issue must necessarily go to a
2:42
referendum, or public vote. We have the
2:44
final say. But there is also the 400
2:47
dimension to this. If the votes reach
2:49
400, meaning two-thirds of the assembly
2:51
, that means a truly overwhelming
2:53
majority. When this number is reached,
2:55
the President can publish the amendment
2:56
directly in the Official Gazette and
2:58
put it into force without needing a
3:00
mandatory referendum. Of course, if
3:01
they wish, they can still ask the
3:03
public at their own initiative. So, in
3:05
summary, the system works like this.
3:07
200 proposes. 360 guarantees a
3:09
referendum. 400 opens the doors
3:11
directly. Section 2. The second step:
3:15
laws and treaties. We are taking one
3:17
step down the pyramid. This is entirely
3:19
the domain of the parliament, which
3:20
holds the legislative power. The laws
3:22
enacted here regulate our daily lives,
3:24
but remember, they can never contradict
3:26
the constitution at the summit. We
3:28
continue with our magic numbers once
3:30
again. Two hundred people are needed
3:32
for the parliament to convene. Yes. But
3:34
the decision quorum required to pass a
3:36
law is a simple majority of those
3:37
attending the meeting. However, under
3:40
no circumstances can this number fall
3:42
below 151, which is one more than
3:44
one-fourth of the total number of
3:46
members. So, 151 is that absolute and
3:48
unchangeable barrier to legislating in
3:50
parliament. Let’s say parliament
3:53
passed a law with 151 votes and sent it
3:55
to the president for publication. The
3:57
president has 15 days. What happens if
3:59
they don't like it, write out their
4:01
reasoning, and veto it back to
4:02
parliament? If parliament insists on
4:04
accepting this law as is, that 151-vote
4:06
threshold is no longer enough, my
4:08
friends. They need the absolute
4:10
majority of the total number of
4:11
parliamentary members, meaning at least
4:13
301 affirmative votes. If they find
4:15
those 301 votes, the president is
4:16
forced to publish that law. However,
4:19
laws are not alone on this step.
4:21
International treaties sit on the exact
4:23
same floor as them. But in 2004, a very
4:25
striking exception was added to our
4:28
system. Normal treaties are equal in
4:30
power to laws. That is fine. But what
4:32
happens if an international treaty
4:34
regarding fundamental rights and
4:35
freedoms, like the European Convention
4:37
on Human Rights, conflicts with our own
4:39
local law? That is when that
4:42
fundamental rights treaty takes a step
4:43
ahead and overrides the law. Incredible
4:46
, right? One tick below the
4:47
constitution, but definitely above
4:49
local laws. Before finishing this floor
4:51
, we must also look at extraordinary
4:53
situations, the moments when things
4:55
change a bit. There is officially a
4:57
chasm between a normal presidential
4:58
decree and a state of emergency decree.
5:01
Decrees issued when a state of
5:02
emergency is declared take an elevator
5:04
in the hierarchy of norms and go
5:06
straight to this second step, right
5:08
next to the laws. They are so powerful
5:09
that they can even restrict fundamental
5:11
rights, and most strikingly, you cannot
5:13
even go to the Constitutional Court for
5:15
their cancellation. It is enough that
5:17
they are submitted for parliamentary
5:18
approval on the same day and decided
5:20
upon within 3 months. 3. Section 3.
5:22
Step: Presidential decrees. Now, we
5:25
safely descend one floor in the pyramid
5:27
to the world of the executive, that is,
5:29
the standard decrees that came with the
5:31
2017 amendment. Let’s recall the
5:34
pyramid’s golden rule out loud once
5:35
again here. The one above overrides the
5:37
one below. Presidential decrees are
5:40
below laws in the hierarchy, and this
5:42
draws the boundaries very clearly. For
5:44
example, you cannot issue a decree on a
5:46
subject clearly regulated by law.
5:48
Let’s say you did. If parliament
5:50
later makes a law on the same subject,
5:51
the decree immediately becomes void and
5:53
goes to the trash. And perhaps most
5:56
importantly, you can never touch
5:58
personal or political rights with a
5:59
normal decree. You can only regulate
6:02
social and economic rights. 4. Section:
6:05
The base, regulations, and
6:07
administrative acts. We are now
6:09
descending to how the wheels of the
6:11
state turn daily, to that operational
6:13
kitchen run by public institutions and
6:14
ministries. Our rule here is very clear
6:17
. A regulation can never be an original
6:20
creator of rules. Think of them like
6:23
the user manual for an electronic
6:24
device you bought. If the device itself
6:27
—that is, a law or decree—is not
6:29
present, the user manual has no meaning
6:31
or power. Right? Regulations are
6:34
entirely secondary. They cannot
6:36
regulate a subject from scratch out of
6:38
thin air without relying on a norm
6:39
above them. 5. Section. The unwritten
6:42
primary source: Customary law. Now, we
6:46
are stepping completely outside this
6:47
rigid written pyramid to reach the
6:49
system's only unwritten source. The
6:51
rules here are not set by parliament or
6:53
ministries. These grow within society
6:56
itself and fill the gaps left by
6:57
written law. But of course, not every
7:01
neighborhood habit carries the force of
7:02
law in court. We need three things. The
7:05
first is the material element. This
7:07
behavior must have been repeated
7:09
consistently over a long period. The
7:10
second is the spiritual element.
7:12
Society must have a general belief that
7:14
this is absolutely necessary. And most
7:16
critically, the legal element, meaning
7:18
the state must recognize it. For
7:20
example, the Turkish Civil Code must
7:22
directly instruct the judge to look at
7:24
customs if there is no written rule. By
7:26
the way, let's also keep in mind that
7:28
due to the principle of "no crime
7:30
without law" in criminal code, custom
7:32
can never be applied. Part. Six.
7:34
Auxiliary sources, court decisions, and
7:36
legal doctrine. We have finished the
7:38
pyramid. Now we move on to the guides
7:40
that show the way to judges in
7:41
difficult situations. Let’s state
7:43
this from the start. In Turkey, judges,
7:45
prosecutors, or professors cannot write
7:48
rules from scratch. Academic articles,
7:50
or doctrine, and previous court
7:52
decisions are only for guidance. They
7:54
are never binding. Separation of powers
7:56
is very clear. Parliament sets the
7:58
rules, the executive implements them,
7:59
and the judiciary interprets them.
8:01
However, we have a very important small
8:02
exception here. Unification of
8:04
jurisprudence decisions. If a
8:06
disagreement arises between the
8:08
internal chambers of the Court of
8:09
Cassation or the Council of State,
8:11
these special rulings given to end the
8:13
confusion are exceptionally and
8:15
absolutely binding for lower courts.
8:17
That’s how it is. From the
8:19
constitution at the top of the power
8:21
pyramid down to the regulations and
8:22
unwritten rules at the bottom, we have
8:24
X-rayed the entire system. This chain
8:27
of rules might seem complex and
8:28
bureaucratic at first, but as citizens,
8:30
this exact hierarchy is the foundation
8:32
of our stability and security. So, as
8:35
we conclude our analysis, I ask you. If
8:38
this unshakable structure, where top
8:39
rules ruthlessly override those below,
8:41
did not exist, how would our cherished
8:43
fundamental rights be protected against
8:45
sudden and arbitrary decisions that
8:47
could be taken overnight? Think about
8:49
it. See you in our next analysis.
Jobs & Education

